Bag review: YSL Saint Laurent wallet on chain & Cassandre purse (in comparison to Chanel WOC)

yves-saint-laurent-wallet-on-chain-2_670

I've gotten lots of questions about this Saint Laurent wallet on chain in caviar leather, and had been waiting to use it more before doing a formal review. Long story short, I’m in love with it and find it to be both beautiful and more importantly, super functional! yves-saint-laurent-wallet-on-chain-1_670
My Chanel caviar wallet on chain is one of my top three favorite bags in my entire wardrobe, so I was thrilled to find a similar functional, convertible purse in a different color scheme. For all my trips this year I've been packing this one with me - it serves well as a cross-body for casual wear (above) and clutch for more formal events (ie. here), all in one.
chanel vs ysl saint laurent wallet on chain purse review
Left: Saint Laurent wallet on chain - in 6 classic colors (mine is called light rose or pale blush)
Right: Chanel wallet on chain (not sold online)

The leather of the Saint Laurent is a pebbled textured caviar leather that feels sturdy, and is very easy to wipe clean. I take this bag everywhere and have had a few mishaps with food and drink, but thankfully everything has wiped right off. The interior of the bag has plenty of little details for organization, very similar to the inside of the Chanel WOC....
There are slots for over 20 cards, a larger pocket behind the back row of card slots, another larger pocket that my lower thumb is holding shut by accident, and a small zippered compartment. The chain strap is removable and snaps on and off. In comparison, the Chanel WOC strap does not come off so I just tuck it inside when using it as a clutch. Being able to remove it vs. having to tuck in is a nice option to have, when every little bit of interior space is valuable!
chanel vs ysl saint laurent wallet on chain purse1
I usually carry the following inside: phone, keys, coins, bunch of cards, sunglasses (only case-less or very slim cases like the Ray Ban ones will fit), and makeup essentials like eyeliner, lip balm, and concealer.
chanel vs ysl saint laurent wallet on chain purse4Although the measurement of the Saint Laruent bag is notably bigger at 9" length x 6" height, it turns out the Chanel WOC does expand quite a bit in depth and can possibly fit the same amount of items. I have never carried sunglasses in my WOC bag though - I don't like expanding the bag quite so much as I'm afraid the snap button will pop open.
chanel vs ysl saint laurent wallet on chain purse5
This brings me to my one and only complaint about the Saint Laurent bag - when the top is closed, there is a tiny gap which you can see below right where the chain comes in and out. Although it hasn't happened to me, I feel like small objects like a pen or eyeliner could potentially fall through. Hence I always keep important small things like keys in the zippered compartment.
chanel vs ysl saint laurent wallet on chain purse2Back view:
chanel vs ysl saint laurent wallet on chain purse3
Here's how it looks with the chain detached:
chanel vs ysl saint laurent wallet on chain purse6
Another thing I love about the Saint Laurent bag is the length of the chain strap is very petite-friendly! See how it compares to the Chanel WOC, for which I always have to tuck an extra length of the strap inside the flap of the purse. The Saint Laurent strap drop length measures approximately 19 inches.
chanel vs ysl saint laurent wallet on chain purse
I hope you guys found this review helpful! Let me know if you have any questions. By the way, Instagram friends know that I actually bought a different bag first - the Cassandre medium with tassel:
YSL
Be still my heart, I still find this to be an absolutely gorgeous and classic purse, down to the clean design and vintage YSL-inspired tassel. I had been looking everywhere for it and ended up having it shipped from a Saint Laurent store in PA. (Big FYI, their brick & mortar store policies are completely different than their online ones. They charge for shipping, and I was surprised to see on my receipt that there are no refunds - only store credit for returns within 10 days). However, upon careful inspection I noticed the bag arrived with scratches already on the calfskin. I felt that with my klutzy habits, this poor bag would be completely stained and scratched up in no time. I was able to return it despite the stringent store policy, due to it arriving damaged. It all worked out for the better because the caviar one is definitely the one for me, but I just wanted to share about the Cassandre for those interested!

59 comments:

  1. I am drooling all over this! Is the snap magnetic, or is it just a plain snap?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. snap is regular button snap. sorta wish it was magnetic but it might be more secure that way i guess.

      Delete
  2. Wow SO GORGEOUS! I know I've made it when I can afford a bag like that ;)

    COOCOO FOR COCO

    ReplyDelete
  3. Soo beautiful :) !

    Pauline
    http://lesselfiesdepauline.blogspot.fr

    ReplyDelete
  4. Very nice. Which strap is heavier?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They are really so similar, it's hard to say!

      Delete
    2. You have great taste!! I purchased the SL in "porcelain" and absolutely love it. The chevron makes the style and it is just so "fresh" looking. The chain is substantial as well. I like it so much will go back for another color:) Well worth the price.

      Delete
  5. I've been loving that bag in your outfits! It's the perfect blush color and the gold detailing is beautiful.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The bag is gorgeous with its color and design! So versatile that the strap comes off. Thanks so much for such a helpful review! After reading this, the bag moved up higher on my want list :)

    xo, Suzie Q
    StyleCueBySuzieQ.com

    ReplyDelete
  7. that's the one thing I don't like about the long length of the WOC, I also have to luck it so that it's shorter for my body frame. However I think that can cause stress to the flap even though it's caviar it still can get damage IMO

    ReplyDelete
  8. Cool. Thanks for sharing.

    Also, I was wondering if you could do a post or YouTube video on how (if) you are integrating Cantonese wedding traditions for your wedding? Particularly if you're choosing to wear the traditional red dress in a modern context?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi there - I am incorporating a traditional Chinese tea ceremony with my family, and also wearing a Qi Pao / cheongsam style dress but not in red. Will do a post with photos after my wedding!

      Delete
    2. Awesome! Can't wait and good luck on your wedding!

      Delete
  9. Hi Jean - what nail polish color do you have on? It's lovely!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! It's Essie Pound Cake (an old one)

      Delete
  10. Some of the leather are too delicate. These are great information. I definitely love the caviar one better too:P

    Shall We Sasa

    ReplyDelete
  11. That bag is just stunning, love the color.

    Diary of Elegance
    http://diaryofelegance.blogspot.ca/

    ReplyDelete
  12. Lovely blush pink YSL bag, it's so pretty and comes with so many compartments! Thanks for the review!


    Prudence
    www.prudencepetitestyle.com

    ReplyDelete
  13. Have you noticed any color transfer from it running against your jeans or other dark bottoms?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So far so good! I feel like that usually happens when dark jeans get wet, though, and I haven't had that issue yet.

      Delete
  14. i really like your sandals with the bling bling heel, where can i find them please.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Kate - they are Dune London brand. I did a post about them earlier last week!

      Delete
    2. don't know how i missed it, thank you :).

      Delete
  15. Its such a gorgeous pink! Love how you've matched the bag and watch as well in your outfit

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thanks so much for this review!! I love both, they look amazing on you. I love these kind of high end reviews, especially for people like me who are debating buying them. Thank you!

    coffeeslag

    Mango Favorites

    ReplyDelete
  17. Thanks so much for this review Jean! This is super helpful and now I definitely know that I want this bag. I love how you compared it to the Chanel WOC as I have that too but I wanted something even roomier but not too heavy on the shoulder. I do wonder about colour transfer as the leather is pebbled and the colour is a blush but I guess a darker colour bag would be easier to maintain.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Makes me wonder what you do for a living. Jeez thats very expensive for a normal person. haha

    ReplyDelete
  19. I really love the color of the YSL bag. I'm a sucker for blush, and I've bought three bags from Tory Burch this year in the same blush shade (whoops!). I'm actually getting use out of each of them, though, since blush is surprisingly easy to wear with anything!
    Julia // Little Miss Haute Couture

    ReplyDelete
  20. Gorgeous I love the pink YSL bag so much!!

    www.tailoredandtrue.wordpress.com

    ReplyDelete
  21. Hi J! Thanks so much for your post! I love how you compared the 2 items and the pictures with all the contents are very helpful! No one else has done this on other blogs and I've been scouring all over. I had one question regarding Chanel WOC; when you tuck in the chain/strap, does it bulk up the wallet and therefore minimize the content potential? You mention the gap it creates on YSL but overall the snap enclosure on both are pretty sturdy, no? Thanks so much! - Min -

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Chanel strap when tucked in takes up a little space, maybe similar to what a piece of makeup would take up, but not terrible. I feel the snap on the YSL is a little sturdier, but that could also be because it's newer vs the Chanel which I've probably snapped open and closed a thousand times now!

      Delete
  22. Still loving the blush for summer! Such a great look!

    www.vanitysalad.com

    ReplyDelete
  23. Hi Jeans, you mentioned that the WOC is one of your top 3 bags. What are the other 2 Jeans? Can you do a post with your most worn handbags and shoes ? thank you in advance.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really can't name a top three, but I knew for sure that the WOC would be amongst those : ) Other bags that I use regularly are my Goyard St Louis tote, my Coach court crossbody, Ann Taylor gallery tote, Tory Burch and Prada convertible strap satchels...it all depends on the occasion though (ie work vs weekend)

      Delete
  24. Nice review my dear!!! YSL is my favorite!!! Have a nice day, kisses from Italy,
    Eni

    Eniwhere Fashion
    Eniwhere Fashion Facebook

    ReplyDelete
  25. Interesting. A helpful element of a review and any comparison is the retail price of each. Can you share that? I wasn't sure if there was a reason you left it out.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The YSL is $1490 in the US as shown in the link (about 25 - 30% less in Europe), and the Chanel I'm really not sure! They aren't sold online and mine is very old.

      Delete
  26. Hi Jean! I would LOVE for you to do a post about how you organize all your beautiful clothes and accessories when you aren't wearing them. Thanks for the inspiration!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Violet - I won't be able to do a post for a while since we're still renovating, but I keep most of my bags in dustbags and store them one inside another (ie. the smaller wallet on chains go inside bigger totes. Bags that don't have anything inside are usually stuffed with large scarves to keep their shape and structure.

      Delete
  27. I felt I ove the Chanel WOC better than YSL, the YSL chain looks little bit cheap compare to Chanel.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Pink bag is amazing and I need the shorts!!!
    xx

    www.mybeautrip.com

    ReplyDelete
  29. I love the color scheme!
    bethanysbling.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  30. Your whole outfit in the second pic is way too cute! I love those neutral sandals <3

    ReplyDelete
  31. Can you please give recommendation on camisole for this sweater and under silk shirts

    ReplyDelete
  32. Your YSL bag is gorgeous. Is the bag comfortable being worn as a crossbody? I got myself a Ferragamo perforated leather Ginny crossbody bag in Macaron (pink) and the strap is rather long if carried on the side (not as crossbody). Wish I had seen this post earlier. :)

    https://sartorialisttoujours.wordpress.com/

    ReplyDelete
  33. Hi I bought the sweater in an xs petite. I find it to be a little boxy looking on me and was thinking I should have ordered an xs regular for a longer , less boxy look. I love the material though it does snag easily. But I guess that's the nature of a linen knit and doesn't reflect so much on quality issues

    ReplyDelete
  34. Hi Jean,
    I'm wondering if you have a sizing/fit review up about the Express jean shorts you're wearing in this post? I'm curious about what size you ordered and how they fit. I normally wear 3-4" shorts, and saw online those are about 2 1/2". Thank you:)
    -Meredith

    ReplyDelete
  35. Hi Jean,
    I was wondering if the chain rubs against the flap of the YSL bag. It looks like there's no wear there in your photos, but I have similar bags where the strap will rub against the leather with noticeable wear and tear. Just wondering if you've had similar experiences after carrying the bag for awhile. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  36. Exceptional,Exquisite..............
    http://indianstylestealer.weebly.com/

    ReplyDelete
  37. You look like Wendy Nguyen..are you in any way related?

    ReplyDelete
  38. Hi Jean! I'm in a bit of a rut and was hoping you could help me. I bought the same YSL bag from the store in New York after seeing it on you! But there were some scratches on the side flap. The leather is chipped just slightly. Would you advise sending the bag back to the store internationally and having it replaced? Have you found that the YSL bag scratches easily or has anything chipped off slightly since you've been using it for a while? Do advise!

    ReplyDelete
  39. Hi Jean, Can I know where did you get the YSL bag? Online or in store? I tried to get one online, unfortunately it was sold out, and I contacted their online representatives, they said the light rose is only sold online, not carried in store. It is so weird. Or anyone get the same bag in same color can give any advice about buying this? Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  40. Hi Jean, I'm debating between a black or blush colored purse. From your experience, which one do you find more versatile? Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  41. Hi Jean,
    I just got a WOC for Christmas and wore it today for the first time with the strap wrapped under once as well to shorten the length and noticed that it had scrunched the edges of the leather just like yours. Curious to know how much use you've gotten out of your WOC and if you've noticed the leather holding the strap has weakened as time has gone by or has basically stayed the same as shown in that photo? It's just too long without wrapping the strap
    Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  42. What color was the YSL marked as when you purchased? Light rose? Or Pale Blush?

    Thank you!!!

    ReplyDelete
  43. Hi Jean, could you please do a wear and tear or a quick update on how the Saint Laurent chain wallet has held up? (e.g. leather softening/prone to scratches/scuffing, gold chain chipping or tarnishing) I'm getting mine in red and after having read reviews about the leather scuffing on thepurseforum I'm just paranoid now, especially when it is an investment. Thanks so much!!!

    ReplyDelete
  44. Hi Jean, that would be so awesome if you can just comment on how well your woc has held up. I am interested in getting their woc as well but didn't want to deal with quality issues if their bags really do not wear well. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  45. hi girls, where can i get an "authentic" ysl chain strap as a replacement. My gfs luxurious made in italy purse seems to have a broken chain now that slips off. She always tells me how knockoff or cheap purses are low quality but i dont see an "authentic" replacement chain at the YSL website. I would absolutely hate to have some substandard cheap chain used on her luxurious purse.

    ReplyDelete
  46. Thanks for the great review! Just got the YSL wallet on chain in black. Can't wait to wear it. There is a current promotion of $200 at Saks that does not exclude YSL, good till end of the month.

    ReplyDelete

 
Pin It button on image hover