A guide to J.Crew Slim wide jeans

j crew sweater, j crew ballet flats, j crew sailor jeans, girls j crew sweater
J.Crew jeans 24 petite c/o (no pocket version), flats 5.5, old tops// On Nori: sailor jeans 5, cardigan S

The slim-wide style might be J.Crew’s best cut of bottoms over the past few years – it was first introduced as cropped jeans, then the cut was eventually offered in chic faux leather (on my wishlist!), chino, and now corduroy. If you’ve been hesitant to try wide leg jeans, these strike a very wearable balance between straight and wide leg that’s gotten rave reviews from petites. You can see some styled in my J.Crew try-on folder which I update regularly!

I wanted to do a mini guide on the different “slim-wide” bottoms I’ve tried on, covering:

  • Length options
  • Waist sizing
  • Non-denim fabrics
  • Best denim wash colors
  • Sailor pockets downsides

slim-wide Lengths:

Petites have lots of choices here depending on if you want a cropped jean, a full length jean to wear with flats, or a longer jean to wear with heels!

Original slim wide jeans (meant to be cropped)
Also applies to corduroy + chino versions.
Petite: 10.75″ rise, 24″ inseam. Hits me right around the ankle bone, as pictured in this post.
Classic: 27″ inseam and actually works well on me as a full length jean with flats. See an older pair on me in Classic sizing, just for the length reference.

Full length slim wide jeans
Petite: 28.5″ inseam. I’m 5 feet tall and would need to wear high heels with this.
Classic: 30″ inseam

j crew sweater j crew bag cheetah print heels
Cashmere cable cardigan xxs c/o, J. Crew jeans “Mila dawn” 24P, heels 5 c/o (similar), suede bag c/o

waist Sizing

J.Crew jeans always run a bit big at the waist for me, but going a full size down can feel too snug to be comfy in all day. So for the slim-wide style, I’d stick with your usual denim waist size (I’m in 24 petite). The only time I definitely size down to 23 petite is with their trouser jeans, which are looser through the hips and legs.

non-denim options

The stretch corduroy literally ONLY has 5 star reviews so far – it’s a thinner cord material and actually felt a little more lightweight and comfortable than denim. I tried on the navy and thought it was so cute, and a work-appropriate alternative to denim!

If you’re a chino girl, this version has plenty of rave reviews from petite customers, with many echoing that the 24″ inseam is excellent for shorties.

Denim washes

A few washes I’ve tried on and would recommend:

  • Resin rinse. I’m LOVING dark rinse denim lately and think it’s a great option that can be dressed up a little more than regular denim. I have on the sailor pocket version above, but would actually recommend the regular pocket version for max versatility (see below).
  • Mila Dawn” wash (pictured below) is one I’ve had for a while and a classic medium-slightly dark denim. Very versatile and only has faint whiskering. Eliz wash goes on sale more often and also seems to be a good 4-season denim color.
  • Ecru – I already have Madewell jeans in this color otherwise would’ve snapped this up at the current sale prices! Very classic off white color with finished, not frayed hems. If you’re petite, this is a good one to consider in either Petite or Classic sizing since I see it very versatile in either length.
jcrew berkeley suede tote bag cashmere cable cardigan fall 2024
Cashmere cardigan xxs c/o, J. Crew jeans 24P, suede bag c/o (the chocolate is gorge)

Sailor pocket considerations

I’m a sucker for cute front pockets and gold buttons, and in warmer weather sailor jeans work great simply with a simple tee or tank. But as we’re heading into Fall, I’ve realized that the jackets and cardigans I usually reach for also have front pockets, and all the pockets at both top and bottom are a bit much together! For this reason, I’ve noticed my slim wide jeans without pockets are more versatile year-round.

If you tend to wear more simple solid tops and sweaters, though, then a pair with the sailor pockets is a great way to add a little interest!

J.Crew jeans 24 petite c/o (no pocket version), flats 5.5, old tops

When you purchase through the links on this blog, I may earn a commission. Thank you for your support!

When you purchase through the links on this blog, I may earn a commission. Thank you for your support!

For Daily Posts

Leave a Comment

8 Comments

  1. Anonymous wrote:

    great review Jean. darker tone bag perfect for fall. one favor to ask of you. could you ask JCrew to bring back their famous Ella open coatigan….such a classic they need to have yearly !ty. lauren

    Posted 10.1.24 Reply
    • Extra Petite wrote:

      Hi! Have you tried this Amazon similar option in tons of colors? While it is not the same quality as J.Crew, I’ve been pretty happy with mine!

      Posted 10.4.24 Reply
      • Anonymous wrote:

        thank you Jean for the recs. I’ll give it a try!

        Posted 10.11.24 Reply
  2. Denise wrote:

    Hi Jean, I was wondering how JCrew slim-wide style compares to the Madewell perfect vintage wide leg jean? Especially around the thigh area, which one is more close-fitting? Thanks so much.

    Posted 9.27.24 Reply
    • Extra Petite wrote:

      Hi! I just compared my two pairs in the same size 24 petite, and the Madewell is about an inch wider around the thighs than the J.Crew. The Madewell jeans are also a tad shorter in rise.

      Posted 10.4.24 Reply
  3. Joanne wrote:

    Hello, love the blue j crew bag but wondered if it is secure with just a snap. Also looking at the Madwell Cresent bag in chocolate raisin. Do you have any suggestions which might be the better option as far as being versatile and practical. thank you

    Posted 9.22.24 Reply
    • Extra Petite wrote:

      Hi Joanne! I haven’t tried on the Madewell bag so can’t speak to that one, but I believe I did see it in stores so I def suggest trying it out on your shoulder! For the J.Crew bag, larger things feel secure in there but for smaller valuables or my wallet I def utilize the inner zipper pouch. This one should also be in most stores so that you can try it on in-person!

      Posted 9.24.24 Reply
  4. Joanne wrote:

    Hello, I love the jcrew purse but wondered if it is secure enough with just the flap to close it and not a top zipper.

    Posted 9.19.24 Reply

Get the newsletter!

What updates would you like?