H&M Reviews: Tweed Jacket, Trench + Mint Sheath Dress

*Get 20% off 1 item with this coupon or download the H&M app to your smartphone & shake. Ends 2/14*

I'm blogging less these days, but still tweeting as I go. Please follow me on Twitter for more timely coupon/deal updates and fitting room photos. Last week, I stopped by H&M and tried on the following (my only purchase was #5):

1. Tweed blazer, item #055671, $40 after coupon (see a size 6 on my friend styled with the silk Blythe blouse). Comes in peach or blue tweed with black trim, and runs about 1 size big compared to most H&M blazers. I'm trying a sz 2 - on me, the shoulders are a bit wide, torso is roomy and the sleeves are long and wide. Would look nice as a work jacket on someone who can fill it out more. The black trim makes these easy to pair with simple black pencil skirts or sheath dresses.

2. Trench coat w/ navy piping, item #032933, $48 after coupon, sz 2 . I'm not in need of another trench, but I wanted to show this for anyone who was. I was drawn to the dark khaki trench material, the expensive-looking tortoiseshell buttons, and the navy piping (love that they didn't skimp on this - it's all around the collar, on the front flap, front pockets, ends of sleeves, and down the back). Sleeves are long for someone my size. They can be shortened, but you'd probably lose the lovely piping.

3. Sheer blouse with pleated bib, item #037371, $24 with coupon. The front of this blouse reminds me of an old J.Crew top that many readers have asked about. I didn't try this on because the color combo does nothing for me, but it might come in other colors!
4. Knit houndstooth pencil skirt, sz XS, $14.36 with coupon. No tag so I couldn't get an item #. XS fits me well but is not snug in the waist like a size 2 would be. To determine whether a skirt is too snug for the office, I like to look at the side view. If it has a tapered \ / pencil shape from the butt/hips down to the knees, then it's fine. If it's starting to curve in under the tush like an "S" shape or curves in the front by the tummy/thighs (like so), then it's too fitted for work.

I liked the shapely look and fit of this skirt (just needs a hem), but passed as I already have a black and white print knit pencil skirt from Ann Taylor. Also as an FYI, it's unlined with a back zipper.

5. Mint sheath dress, sz 2, item #059894, $40 after coupon. I fell completely in love with the color and shapely bottom of this dress. It's from H&M "Trend," which is slightly pricier than their regular line, but I feel like the quality is noticeably better.

Features include: Seamless dolman/kimono-style sleeves, single wide pleat down the front, side bottom panels, tapered below-the-knee pencil skirt, back zipper, and lower slit (the type that's actually possible to make longer when you hem the length). Material is a thick stretch ponte. This retro-inspired silhouette would be so effortlessly chic on someone taller. On my 5' tall self, however, a hem is needed plus high heels to balance out the wider top half.
Update: Here's how the sleeves look when the arms are down (& hem pinned up):

Between this mint dress and the emerald one hanging in my closet, I'm trying to pick one keeper. Both are below-the-knee pencil sheath dresses in a spring shade of green, and cost the same (after an additional discount for makeup on the mint). Here are my thoughts:

Mint:
+ I don't own anything in that color, can be worn to work, stretch ponte is more comfortable
- Top half is trendier than what I typically wear & can overwhelm a small frame if not balanced out

Emerald:
+ More classic silhouette
- Can't be worn to work (due to neckline), pulls across the back on me, thin material so some lining shows

Nick prefers the mint because it reminds him of what ShoeMart (Filipino department store) salesladies wear. What can I say - I was inspired by our recent trip : )

Readers - Mint or emerald?

118 comments:

  1. I like the silhouette of the mint dress but not sure if I like the sleeves.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Upon first glance, the mint gave me the impression of a hospital operating gown. Sorry, didn't want to be rude...just wanted to be honest. The mint is such a pretty colour though. I think the color would be nice as a blouse. In the end, your judgement is best.

    ReplyDelete
  3. i like the mint!

    ReplyDelete
  4. The shape and material look phenomenal for the mint dress - but the color is too surgeon/scrub-like.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Love the mint dress - it reminds me of something Victoria Beckham would design.

    Did you get to visit Manila? We went to Shoemart and Rustans a lot when we were there. Hope to see a post on your trip (studies permitting!)

    I also think the trench looks amazing on you - but since you have Burberry ones, nothing else can compare.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The emerald one looks hot on you! :) There's something funny going on under your armpit with the mint dress. It looks like it doesn't fit right. The neckline also looks boring and seems a bit middle-aged.

    ReplyDelete
  7. In the spirit of being critical on purchases, I say keep neither. The mint dress is gorgeous but I think the dolman sleeves look awkward on the non-flowly ponte material. Something about the dress is reminiscent of a 60s flight attendant. :/ I much prefer the color and silhouette of your emerald one. Maybe you could wear a cami or mock cami underneath to cover cleavage?

    ReplyDelete
  8. Emerald!! The top part of the mint looks too frumpy/weird. Emerald looks gorgeous on you!!

    ReplyDelete
  9. I like mint more than emerald! The mint one is beautiful!!!

    ReplyDelete
  10. I love the mint one but I think the emerald is more of a keeper because of the better fit. Anyway you can keep both?! :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. I really like the houndstooth pattern of that pencil skirt. (Great tip btw! Will keep that in mind.)

    Both dresses are pretty, but I say keep the mint because you don't own anything in that colour. I am still bugged about the sleeves though - mainly because it has an awkward slouch at the underarms. I prefer dolman sleeves to be wider so people can actually tell it's a dolman sleeve and not just a baggy shirt.

    P.S. just read the hospital gown comment...although it does give that impression, I certainly didn't think of that when I first saw it on you!!

    ReplyDelete
  12. I think for this case, it is neither. Not sure about the shoulder to sleeve line. Thanks for asking for our opinion!

    - L

    StyleHills.com

    ReplyDelete
  13. I love the emerald and have it myself, but the mint is much more unique in design and colour. So if you have another green dress already, I say go for the mint!

    ReplyDelete
  14. I agree on keeping the mint green dress too, its really unique and looks like its straight from the runway.

    ReplyDelete
  15. That's a tough choice, but I'm leaning towards the emerald green. I really like the tailoring/seaming details, especially around the waist.

    ReplyDelete
  16. love that houndstooth skirt! would look fab when hemmed. don't like the sleeves on the mint dress though, sorry!

    ReplyDelete
  17. lol SM saleslady uniform! i think they've changed their uniforms :)

    ReplyDelete
  18. Where do you work?

    ReplyDelete
  19. The emerald looks much better on you and I think it can be worn to work with a cardigan layered on top.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Thanks for the reviews. Btw, where are your boots from? So cute!

    ReplyDelete
  21. Neither sorry :(

    ReplyDelete
  22. Personally, I think that you should keep the mint dress! Comparing the two, I think the mint is better fitting, and (in my biased opinion) a better shade of green.

    xx maggie
    saltandleather

    ReplyDelete
  23. That's tough because both look beautiful on you but I think I am leaning towards the mint! =)

    ReplyDelete
  24. I like the mint one more but the sleeves looks kinda funny. o.o Maybe you can cut it off. LOL.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Oooh I just got the pink tweed blazer the other day! Full priced in Canada unfortunately :( Really loving that blazer though; definitely gotta try to hunt that one down~

    And I say emerald. The colour looks gorgeous on you :)

    <3 emi
    http://emicablyyours.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  26. I love both. The white one has an amazing cut, but the other one is a gorgeous colour.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Emerald! I do not like the top of the mint dress - it's too much and overwhelms your petite figure.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Too bad they don't have the mint dress in an emerald color! Although I love the emerald color, the mint color dress gives me the effortlessly 50s vibe. I feel that with the proper hemming and accessory, the mint dress would be a better fit for your closet. Not to mention the versatility of being able to use the dress for work and play!

    ReplyDelete
  29. I'm really curious what the mint dress looks like with your arms down. With you hand on your hip, it shows off the dolman portion (as I'm sure was your intention) and there's something odd looking about it. Maybe I'm not used to a dolman sleeve on a fitted dress? I like the color of both and would ordinarily vote emerald but it seems a little limiting since you can't wear it to work.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh! Good point about the arms down! I think the dolman sleeves can look good on more flowy materials, but since this is a thicker knit, it may look strange.

      Jean - Both these items "as is" are a no. I like your idea of higher hems for both. The mint sleeves are just bugging me. Not just the armpit area, but the sleeves in general are not flattering enough on you. You have such nice arms, they are hiding them!

      But...all these impressions could be changed once the mint one is styled. It is a fun canvas to work with! And you did say Nick liked it.

      And congratulations on your newest endeavor! I just Googled what the CFA III test is. :p With all this preparation you will do great! :)

      Delete
    2. Good point, SPG + Michelle! I just added a pic with arms down. I think it looks pretty normal down despite the thicker material.

      Delete
    3. I want to love it because everything is so beautiful - color, chest "stripe", and overall fit but I'm still not digging the sleeves. The dolman looks accidental (I hope that doesn't come across as too harsh). That said, I'm far from a fashion expert so if you love it, and it seems like you do, keep it! :)

      Delete
  30. Hi Jean! I'm loving the mint colors on all the new spring lines but the cut on this dress isn't very flattering... Keep the emerald dress and wait til you find a mint dress in a cut that you love.

    ReplyDelete
  31. I like them both! But yeah, the emerald neckline is too low for what i normally see you in for work. But I do like the sillouhete on that emerald one better. If you don't pick the emerald green, I'll buy it off of you. (= I've been looking for more dresses like that (not for work of course) but as you know, Hawaii isn't cool enough to have H&M so I've been having a hard time finding one elsewhere.

    ReplyDelete
  32. The tweed skirt looks nice! I love the colors of both the emerald and mint dresses. I really wanted the emerald one but couldn't find it :( The mint one, I'm liking everything but the sleeves. I wonder how it looks with your arms down to your sides?

    ReplyDelete
  33. Disclaimer: Both look great on you; you are one of those lucky girls who can pull off almost anything. But if I HAD to vote one or the other, I'd vote emerald. I don't know if it's just the photo, but there's something a little awkward about the way the shoulders/sleeves of the mint one sit. Maybe it's just a little big in the shoulders? It just doesn't have that "made for you" look that so many of your other clothes have.

    As for the emerald, the color is just so vivid and refreshing, it shows off your slender waist, and it has such lovely, elegant lines that it is still flattering, even though it is a longer length. I also think it could easily be made work-appropriate with a cami or a cardigan.

    ReplyDelete
  34. I vote for the mint!

    Also, I didn't comment on the Jason Wu post, but I just wanted to say, good call in offering them to your friends. I was in love with the collection from the lookbook, and even lined up early for it, but I've decided to return the 2 clothing items I bought after further consideration in front of the mirror.

    ReplyDelete
  35. I like the mint, more expensive looking.

    I have that trench! - except I bought it last year in Feb in NYC when I was on holidays. They must have remade it for this season :)

    ReplyDelete
  36. Definitely the emerald. Better fit and shade.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Emerald. The dolman isn't working for me in the mint one. It's definitely a great shade for you. You'll find something else in that shade as it's very 'in' right now. More spring releases will come and so will a better dress. Love the color & fit of the emerald. Also looks cute w/your blouse for the 2nd look you shared. Good luck deciding.

    ReplyDelete
  38. I usually love mint colour, but in this case the emerald definitely definitely suits you more :) mint dress looks too overwhelming on you...

    ReplyDelete
  39. argh I hate big sizes! I just bought a blazer from h&m that I'm supposed to tailor myself to make it fit :P got encouraged from our writings.. actually! I've been buying loads of stuff (shirts, skirts..) that do not fit but now that I know that I have the possibility to MAKE them fit, it feels like a whole new world of clothes have appeared! :D previously I've only bought clothes that fit perfectly (except dresses that I can easily change) and I really didn't buy that much :) so big thank you for your blog!

    ReplyDelete
  40. Emerald! The color of the mint dress is really lovely, but the dress itself is underwhelming. The emerald dress looks amazing on you!

    ReplyDelete
  41. I like the mint on you :) The dress will look great on you with your hair up and a few nice accessories :) I've just start blogging come by and take a look at my blog :)

    ReplyDelete
  42. Definitely mint!

    ReplyDelete
  43. ShoeMart! I hope your adventures in the Philippines included some shopping, haha.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Mint! The shade looks more subtle and expensive than the emerald. It also looks so elegant with the pearls and belt that you accessorized it with in the last photo. Plus it's not very easy to find a dress in that shade in stores.

    ReplyDelete
  45. The mint is an awesome color on you and seems have more versatility...but it definitely needs some tailoring.

    ReplyDelete
  46. i think the mint is gorgeous! and it would be better to have the more covering one than to be limited to only wearing it out on the town.

    ReplyDelete
  47. Get the mint one hon! You look so great in that dress!

    xoxo
    www.natashafatah.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  48. Mint surely is the "trend" color, but I prefer the shape of the emerald dress on you. Also, it gives more visual balance to your dark hair :-)

    ReplyDelete
  49. Tough decisions! For the kelly green dress, if it looks tacky/cheap and is too low cut for comfortable wear, i'd say save your bucks. For the mint dress,I hope you are planning to tailor the sleeves cos its still a little roomy at the armpits. The colour and the fitting at the hips is great. The length after hemming is perfect. If not, go for the right fit over colour! :))

    ReplyDelete
  50. Thanks for the always thorough review Jean!

    I love the mint green dress on you, it's a color that I have been yearning for too, and I think the dress is very different (in a good way) and will be welcomed addition to your wardrobe. I really liked the kelly green dress on you too but since I own it I sort of know all of its faults well so if you can't keep both then I would vote for you to keep the mint green one.

    I saw everything else you tried on in stores recently but didn't get a chance try them on. I am loving all the Spring arrivals though...I picked up this fairly well made baby pink long blazer in a knit material (also available in baby blue) with gold buttons. I can't decide if I should keep it so I might post pics and ask you for your opinion! :)

    ReplyDelete
  51. The mint! It's a different style than you usually wear (more mod) which is good for stretching outside of ones comfort zone. May I suggest trendier accessories/styling than the ones you have pictured with it? I think shiny black/black patent belt, shoes would be a fab contrast to the pale green!

    ReplyDelete
  52. I'm a bit torn, I'm not really sure either is the perfect item. I love the sleek line of the mint dress, and the color (which does work well for you too), but THOSE SLEEVES! Ugh, can they be altered easily? It's just too much dumpiness for your slender arms, IMO. On first glance I'd have voted for the emerald green, but the slight puckering in the back is bothering me. You are so slim, so it's a sign of a poor quality dress vs. you being too heavy for it. And the neckline is bothersome. It seems too fitted to wear a cami with it too (shame).
    I would opt for continuing the hunt. A perfect green dress is out there for you. Or else, tailor the mint one (including sleeves).

    ReplyDelete
  53. although I've seen all the pictures I am still thinking of the first one... those blazers are incredible beautiful!!

    ReplyDelete
  54. Keep them both! They both look great on you.

    ReplyDelete
  55. I really like the mint. It is a different color than you normally wear.

    ReplyDelete
  56. I think the emerald dress is much easier to wear and the bright color looks better on you than the mint. Also, the dolman sleeves look weird on that dress.

    ReplyDelete
  57. The emerald is infinitely more flattering on you... : )

    ReplyDelete
  58. I like the emerald, but mostly because I like the color, so it may not be the most practical choice!

    The tweed blazer is cute, I wish I had a need for something like that.

    ReplyDelete
  59. Emerald for sure :]

    ReplyDelete
  60. The Emerald dress! So classy. You look great!

    xoxo,

    ReplyDelete
  61. I love the mint color but the fit on the emerald is fab and the color looks great with your skintone.

    ReplyDelete
  62. I say keep the emerald. I love the mint color on you, but the silhouette isn't very flattering. I wish they hadn't done the sleeve and shoulders like that.

    ReplyDelete
  63. Emerald all the way. The mint color just doesn't make up for the awkward dolman sleeves

    ReplyDelete
  64. Mint!! It looks so mod and trendy. The emerald is too plain. And I loooooove that trench coat! :)

    ReplyDelete
  65. I'm torn! The mint color looks wonderful on you, and I love that pleat in the front. However, I think I'm just not a fan of dolman sleeves in that non-flowy ponte material. I don't know that it would look much better on someone taller- the extra material would still have too much shape! On the other hand, the mint dress does fit a little better in the body than the emerald, and being able to wear it to work is a plus. My vote is tentatively for the emerald, but I want a third choice. :)

    ReplyDelete
  66. Mint makes you look very thin I like the emerald

    ReplyDelete
  67. Emerald for sure. Even thought you don't think the fit is great for the emerald one with the back pulling, etc. I don't really notice the back pulls all that much. The proportions work better for your body and overall, you can get away with no alterations on it. It's also a color you can wear in the summer or winter months, where as the lovely minty color is pretty much only for the warmer temperatures. Also, the dolman sleeves on such a structured, thick material, is kind of strange-looking. Even when pinned up, it makes you look like you have really big shoulders with strange sleeve length.

    ReplyDelete
  68. The mint looks gorgeous on you.

    ReplyDelete
  69. I would go with the mint. It's perfectly appropriate for work and I feel like with some interesting accessories, you can totally wear this for a night out. While I get your concern about the trendier top half, I think it's still subtle enough where you won't get swallowed by the trend.

    ReplyDelete
  70. I love the mint one as is!

    ReplyDelete
  71. I love the color and fabric of the mint one, but I think the emerald one fits much better in the upper torso.

    ReplyDelete
  72. Emerald looks like it fits you much better on the top. Love the color too!

    ReplyDelete
  73. In the spirit of honesty, the mint dress does not fit you at all. It is completely unflattering on top and does nothing to give your tiny bottom any shape. And don't even get me started on that color...The emerald dress is beautiful! The color is fantastic on you and the cut is so flattering! With the right accessories you could wear it almost all year round as well. I don't think it is low-cut at all, but if you are uncomfortable just throw a scarf on. Thank you for letting your readers comment as if we are your bff's!!

    ReplyDelete
  74. Emerald! I love the mint color because it is so "in" with the trends around pastel colors. But I have to agree with the many commenters above that the fit is rather odd looking around the sleeves when your hands are not on your hip. I'd say go with the emerald and wear a cami underneath. That is what I do with all my low cut shirts to work. I actually layer them over lululemon workout tops (the power y tank) because those have a built in bra and are super comfortable and long :). Also - the emerald color looks gorgeous on you! I also love it with the shirt layered over it!

    ReplyDelete
  75. emerald!
    fits you much MUCH better.

    ReplyDelete
  76. MINT!

    It's a more interesting (even though it's trendy now, the top half has a classic vibe to it), the color is more sophisticate and the comfortableness of the fabric and therefore the dress trumps all of the above. The emerald dress is a dime-a-dozen sort of the dress.

    ReplyDelete
  77. Great post. Now onto my 2 cents: both are great but if you were to pick one then the EMERALD one does it for me personally. SLeeves on te mint one could fit better whereas Shape and colour of the emerald one complement your body and skin colour VERY WELL. Finally what I do is put a thin white or black slip top inside to offset the low neckline and it works just fine for the offi. cheers, S

    ReplyDelete
  78. I love the both!

    http://www.patcandytips.com

    ReplyDelete
  79. i have emerald one and found a simple tank at old navy same colour just to wear underneath and makes it a little more modest plus color is really nice on you

    ReplyDelete
  80. i love the first one! it's super chic and such a great price.

    xo

    ReplyDelete
  81. MINT!!

    I'm loving that dress =)

    ReplyDelete
  82. Emerald flatters your skin tone much better and fits nicer!

    ReplyDelete
  83. That mint dress is so beautiful on you! Definitely prefer the shorter hemline on you....Man I love that color!!

    ReplyDelete
  84. i love mint! and I ADORE that trench coat! ♥

    http://highprofilehighexpectations.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  85. keep both! I really like both cuts and colors on you!

    -Nico

    ReplyDelete
  86. I don't think the dolman sleeve really reads properly on the mint dress. It just ends up looking ill-fitting on the top.

    ReplyDelete
  87. You have a darling figure so everything looks so nice on you. To echo another reviewer, you make cheap clothes look expensive!

    But my vote this time is to return both. The emerald green color looks dynamite on you and although the dress fits well, it is not that versatile and the material doesn't look that great and you might not want to reach for it after a few wears. As for the mint, I cannot really tell from the pic (maybe it is the H&M lighting) but the mint does not appear to flatter your skintone. Also, are the shoulders padded? It looks like it.

    ReplyDelete
  88. I wanted to buy that blazer in blue! I saw it one day, then realized I wanted it and went back for it the next but it was gone!! I've been calling my local H&M since to see if they've had any new shipments, but so far no luck! Hope I can find it again...!

    And as for the mint dress, the sleeves just look off--someone mentioned the dolman sleeve doesn't quite fit, and I agree. The rest of the dress is fitted but the sleeve is awkward, I find.

    ReplyDelete
  89. I love that mint dress on you! Its such a beautiful color and shape. I've been calling around to all my H&M and none of them carry the Trend line sadly. I wish they had online shopping available or I wish I knew someone who lived near a store that does to have them purchase it for me.

    ReplyDelete
  90. Ooooo, I like the blazer and the skirt. Unfortunately since the blazer is a bit large on you and the skirt fits you just right in the waist, there's no way they would fit me. Bummer. But out of curiosity, when you find a skirt that fits in the waist, if you hold it up in front of you without putting it on, does it look like it will fit? I feel like I read about people with my waist measurement (23") finding waists that don't need to be taken in, but when I go into stores, the ones I try on are way too large, so I just start breezing through by holding skirts up to me and the waists all LOOK so big that I don't even try on. But if that sort of assessment is completely off I'll start sucking it up and put them all on!

    Also, if anyone is more petite than Jean, Zara Kids is also selling a tweed blazer for $35. I just ordered it yesterday, so we'll see how it fits in person!

    http://www.zara.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/product/us/en/zara-us-S2012/190011/667016/TWEED%2BJACKET

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Here's a review of the Zara Kids jacket at thepetitebow.com http://t.co/byjYWOKz

      Delete
  91. I love the emerald dress...not really digging the mint one, although I do like the pleat on the front. Mostly I just don't like the color! My vote is emerald, hemmed, with cami or mock cami for work.

    ReplyDelete
  92. Emerald for sure! The mint colour is gorgeous but the dolman sleeves don't work with the material.

    ReplyDelete
  93. You have a lovely figure, but the dolman cut just looks awkward and ill-fitting somehow. I vote you return both and wait for something perfect.

    ReplyDelete
  94. Great coat!! love, love it! xoxo <3 www.rubygirlblog.com

    ReplyDelete
  95. OK--now that I saw the mint with the arms down, I like it much better & think it's more flattering. That said, I still think the emerald is a much prettier and more vivid color, and that the neckline of the emerald is much more flattering. So...I think I still vote emerald. But by a much narrower margin!

    ReplyDelete
  96. Emerald is great. Fits you better :)

    ReplyDelete
  97. I am loving mint right now, but I really think the emerald dress looks the best on you! It looks gorgeous with your skin tone....and I am not really digging the sleeves on the mint dress, no matter how great the color.

    ReplyDelete
  98. I'm thinking about hunting down the mint dress and make it sleeveless.
    The dress on its own looks quite granny, but you make it look cute!

    ReplyDelete
  99. the mint, tweed and trench is so a must have!!! the skirts too but definitely the tweed!

    http://harperandmonroe.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  100. the trench looks great!

    If anyone is seeking a quality tweed jacket, I've just posted about one that Lastcall.com is now having on sale and I just ordered: http://dressedinpieces.blogspot.com/

    Not sure if it's petite friendly though.

    ReplyDelete
  101. Love these pics, after seeing the trends from NYFW I must get myself some boucle/tweed and dogstooth print! That jacket is cute in both colours and I love mint for spring!
    http://paulatasker.squarespace.com/

    ReplyDelete
  102. Mint. I have it myself. I love it!!!

    Take a look here: http://atlantic-pacific.blogspot.com/2012/03/minty-fresh.html

    ReplyDelete

I love hearing your comments and opinions.

Please do not post a blog or giveaway link here (unless relevant). Thank you!

 
Pin It button on image hover