Finding the Right Skirt Length (Petite Edition)

In your opinion, which of the skirt lengths below look best on me?

A. 2 inches past the knee; B. at the knee; or C. 2 inches above the knee:
Please, please excuse the zombie expressions and gnarly hair in this post. I couldn't bother to get dolled up for these photos.

A while back, one of my readers (thanks Elaine!) emailed me a link about determining one's ideal skirt length. The formula seems complicated, but the concept is simple: the most visually appealing skirt length shows 50% skirt and 50% leg. I will now walk through the "formula" ...


 This will be the cover of my first book, titled "How to Look 10 Years Old."
Formula to find your ideal skirt length:

Step 1. Measure from your hipbone (that protruding bone) to the middle of your kneecap. This is A. For me, A = 17 inches.

Step 2. Measure from the middle of your kneecap to the middle of your anklebone. This is B. For me, B = 13 inches.

Step 3. A-B = discrepancy between your leg proportions. For me, this is 17-13 = 4 inches. 

Step 4. Divide the number from Step 3 by 2. For me, this is 4 / 2 = 2 inches. 2 inches is my "Magic Number."

Now, if you have short calves (A is greater than B), your ideal skirt length should be kneecap minus Magic Number. Per this formula, my ideal skirt length is 2 inches above the knee.

If you have long calves (A is less than B), your ideal skirt length should be kneecap plus Magic Number.

Do I personally follow this formula? Loosely, maybe. There are some "variables" that the formula does not factor in, for example:

- Heels. 3 inch heels elongate the lower leg visually by at least 2 inches.
- High-waisted skirts versus low-waisted skirts. The formula has you measure beginning at your hipbone, assuming that is where the skirt will be slung.

To mitigate these variables, I wore flats in all three photos and wore ninja black to distract from the waist of the skirt. I do agree that above the knee looks best on me, but knee-length should also be okay with heels. A brief look into my skirt history...


Above the knee 
(17.5" H&M on left, 14" H&M on right)

At the knee 
(20" Theory on left, 21" Ann Taylor Petites on right)

Hope this wordy post wasn't too boring. For those who actually did the "formula"... do you have short calves or long calves? Where do you prefer your skirt lengths to hit?

66 comments:

  1. I prefer the "at the knee".
    It gives the illusion of more height<3

    I think I like the "at the knee" length on you too~

    VERY helpful post, thanks!^___^

    XOXO
    Miss. P

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree. I like the at the knee on her best. She is so cute, though, they all look pretty good.

      Delete
    2. i also think at the knee looks best on her too. this is very helpful! thanks!

      Delete
  2. Awesome post! Love the visuals - that really helps. Off to add this to my list of petite links ... :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I feel you the skirt looks great 2 inches above the knee for you. When measuring the proportions, was there any mention about longer body types or different builds? Usually petite people look better in mini dresses than really tall people, who look great in maxis. But I do see what you mean with the heels. It does look better right at the knee cap when wearing heels since they elongate the legs.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Interesting formula! I never thought about it so mathematically haha. Usually I stick to shorter lengths (1-2 inches above the knee) to maximize height and also because I want to avoid my calf area. If I go below the know, the hem hits at the calf and cuts me off at a very wide point.

    Shoes also count, as you mentioned, the "x-factor". With shorter skirts, I wear flats to minimize potential skankiness and with at-the-knee skirts, I slip on heels.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I never thought there was a formula for an ideal skirt length. According to the formula, my ideal length is 1.5 inches above my knee but I prefer going shorter and it depends on the type of skirt. I like to go shorter for flared styles at right above the knee for office styles. Cool post!

    ReplyDelete
  6. How cool! At the knee is my favorite on you, and I see how heels can play a factor in that.

    I measured once and got 1 as my magic number, but then I did it again and got 0.5...I suck at measuring... =P

    ReplyDelete
  7. Awesome post! I definitely like at the knee look on you but the shortest length looks great too!!!

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I think the above knees (last pic of the 3) look best on you! I did mine and my magic number is 1. I'm thinking.. will it look right?

    ReplyDelete
  10. i think the ones above the knees look best. being extremely short myself, wearing shorter skirts or shorts elongate my legs, and paired with heels or wedges make them look more lean and defined. the trick obviously is not to go to short though! great post!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Silly, you are one of the most gorgeous girls I've ever seen! Gar, I'm jealous :D

    I like #3, just above the knee... I think it elongates your figure :)

    Love,
    Aya ( strawberrykoi.blogspot.com )

    ReplyDelete
  12. Very interesting. Which is best if you thighs and calves are the same length?

    ReplyDelete
  13. gah you are so gorgeous! this post is really helpful, if only I had gorgeous gams like you! I like the "at knee" length, but the shorters suit you too!

    <3jimin

    ReplyDelete
  14. Ooh! This is very helpful : ) I'll have to measure and figure out my magic number when finals are over. I have short calves and really long upper leg .. so I look strange in skirts sometimes xD

    ReplyDelete
  15. Very interesting post! A is a definite no-no, B is good for work, and C is best if you're wearing flats. I'll have to whip out the measuring tape sometime and see what my magic number is!

    ReplyDelete
  16. I like the "at the knee" look best on you, but then the shorter lengths look nice too! And it is always nice to have a little bit of variety in skirt lengths for different heel heights and business vs. casual occasions.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Wow this is the first time I've come across your blog & I really like it!
    I'm definitely following~! <3

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hmm I wear all lengths actually, though I usually go for at or above the knee as anything that hits near mid-calf just makes me stumpy. Skirt lengths is one of the only things that makes me enjoy being short since that means I can wear shorter lengths without looking skanky!

    ReplyDelete
  19. At the knee on you when wearing heels! Very curious because I always thought shorter skirts automatically meant looking taller, but your silhouette looks longer and leaner in the at-the-knee pics!

    Also your 10-year-old picture is how I usually look. :D Shorts and flats, yay.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I would definitely have to vote.....above the knee. It just looks better!

    ReplyDelete
  21. B. the knee length. above the knee makes you look shorter the below the knee doesn't flatter you at all... though the succeeding pictures are all pretty :)

    ReplyDelete
  22. above the knee is just perfect for you! but like you said, at the knee is do-able if wearing heels. it looks just fine too.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Agreed! On petite women, I think above the knee looks best.

    It's the same for myself -- I like skirts at knee length, but only with knee high boots or heels.

    If not, skirts JUST above the knee (but not any higher as I'm 5'4") tend to look the best on me.

    If not, I just look frumpy.

    ReplyDelete
  24. cool post, very informative

    In my opinion, at the knee looks best on you

    roxy
    http://roxybeautyblog.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  25. It not only has to do with the length of the leg, but the width as well. You do NOT want a skirt to hit at your calves or exactly at your knee. These tend to be wider parts of the leg and will automatically make you look shorter. While I prefer 1-2 inches above the middle of the knee, you really need to find the most slender part of the leg and make sure the skirt shows that part. It will elongate the look.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Great post. Even though I am 4'11, for work I usually do at the kneed with no tights but with tights I let myself wear a shorter skirt.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Depending on the occasion but I like it at the knee since I too don't have much to work with. I love the fact that i can get away with shorter skirts though.

    Thanks for this post, really enjoyed it.

    ReplyDelete
  28. This is awesome. Thanks for sharing!

    And thanks for entering my giveaway! I'm a new follower. :)

    ReplyDelete
  29. In your experiment -- given the skirt shape -- I prefer at the knee as well (though I think .5 inch shorter might be even better). The 2" above looks good but not quite *as* good.

    In your example photos, I think knee-length looks stunning and the 14" with tonal heels/tights makes you look super-leggy. So with your leg shape you really can't go too wrong!

    I have not had coffee yet so no way am I attempting the measuring...but I'm a sucker for all such formulas so will try later, thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  30. Wow this post is awesome! I love your mathematical approach to finding the ideal skirt length.

    The title of your book (silly girl) is hilarious. I love it.

    love you in that knee length theory skirt, & that vibrant pink looks great on you!

    Steph

    ReplyDelete
  31. Great tutorial! Not too sure if I would follow this to strictly but I do love skirts that are just above the knee. You do look really young in the picture of you in shorts!

    Thanks for taking the time to visit my blog!

    I saw pictures of the kid stam and was instantly heartbroken that they don't have it anymore. I've been rethinking the stam and will look into either the "little stam" or the "cecilia". It is heavy in person.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Way to take the formula and make a great visual tutorial out of it! You illustrated it beautifully. Keeping these principles in mind helps with online shopping too, since we can't always assume a skirt or dress i going to look the same on us as the model!

    ReplyDelete
  33. i had a question, what if you have big calf muscles?

    ReplyDelete
  34. oh i love your blog and your reviews and tips! :) So before I thought i was petite... but i guess NOT REALLY. haha because I'm 5'3" and like 95lbs... so KINDA? lol.. but thanks for all of your reviews, ya!

    oh yeah! I have a question, i read that you have taken your first step of the CFA exam. is it hard? I think i'm taking it next year :( YIKES!!!

    ReplyDelete
  35. Hey Diane, I honestly am not so sure about the big calf muscles. I looked at some photos online, and agree with what a reader mentioned above - it's important to have a skirt (or shorts) end at a narrow part of your leg. If it ends at the wide part of your leg like the middle of the calf, then it may be unflattering. Sorry I am not much help!

    Kellie - You definitely are petite ... 5'4" and below is fairly petite, and you're my weight plus 3+ inches taller .. wow! The first level of the CFA wasn't bad, but the second level is daunting to me. It will probably take me a year to get through the 7 books, so I postponed Level II until next year - it sucks that it's only once a year. Best of luck to you, though!

    ReplyDelete
  36. great post and super informative!!!

    ReplyDelete
  37. I most like the one 2 inches above your knee, you could probably also use one an inch or two longer than the longest skirt.
    My sewing teacher always say. A skirt should hit your leg at a point where the leg goes in. to make the legs look slim. I am petite, but have really solid legs, so I always go for mid-calf length or rarely just above the knees, since those are the only points where my legs curve in.
    Tania

    ReplyDelete
  38. Just stumbled across your blog...5'2" here. My A = 19"; B = 16", so I'm short-calved. I typically buy skirts to fall around the knee or just below (I almost always wear 2-3" heels though). My thinking had been that a) that length is work-appropriate and b) just below my knee cap is right before where my calf gets really muscular.

    Last year when I started running a lot more, I decided I'd invest in some flats to throw in the mix so I wasn't risking issues with my leg muscles/knees/feet 5 days a week -- and with flats, I feel like I can justify wearing skirts just above the knee to work.

    ReplyDelete
  39. This is so confusing.I have 26" inseam you said you have 28" inseam, but I just measured my outseam and the results were exatly like urs. 13/17. are you sure ur measurment is right? I just don't get how somebody with 28" inseam can have the same leg length as a 26" inseam.or maybe ur iseam is 26". idk.
    it's no big deal, but I'm just curious.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Interesting post. Something to keep in the back of my mind when I shop for skirts.
    Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  41. I realy think that if one doesn not have nice legs, then they should avoid minis. They simply don´t look nice on chunky legs, or legs that are just not nice. Doesn´t matter what height the person is.

    ReplyDelete
  42. I actually think you look the best in the knee length skirts you posted! It really depends on the type of skirt though.

    ReplyDelete
  43. I like above the knee lenght, you look awsome.
    I am near 40,5'0, size 1 petite, would be ok a so short skirt for my age?
    i dont look old. ( at least I think I don´t)

    ReplyDelete
  44. I tend to think above the knee looks great on petite people :) you look great in at-the-knee too! My magic number is 3, I'd like to think I suck at measuring but in all honesty I have really short calves...My A = 18" and my B = 12". Yikes.

    ReplyDelete
  45. I have short calves so I prefer above the knee =]
    Although I am like you and I don't think I will follow the formula so strictly because your eyes are always the best "formula" (if that makes any sense) ;D

    ReplyDelete
  46. you actually look pretty stumpy in the short skirts despite showing more leg.I don't know where you have it in your mind that wearing shorter skirts make you look taller.

    ReplyDelete
  47. Thank you for your useful post! My magic number is 3. But personally, I think that is scantily clad So I usually choose one inch above the knee.Is this too conservative?

    ReplyDelete
  48. Thank you so much, this was very helpful :D

    ReplyDelete
  49. I've gotten taller since you first posted this but it still holds true. My thigh and my calves measure exactly the same, 18", and I really do look best with knee length skirts.

    ReplyDelete
  50. I've gotten taller since you first posted this but it still holds true. My thigh and my calves measure exactly the same, 18", and I really do look best with knee length skirts.

    ReplyDelete
  51. At the the knee or just above looks best. As a rule of thumb, higher the skirt, higher the heels.

    ReplyDelete
  52. This is interesting...Are most people's A-B measurements a difference of 4"? Mine are and so are my friend's sister's and mom's...

    ReplyDelete
  53. Your blog is so necessary, I thought the knee length looked best on you and I noticed how your demeanor/attitude shifted in different skirt lengths as well. To me the shorter skirt length made you look childish, in a way, if you want to look younger than you already are. The knee length skirt made you look sophisticated and the clothes looked better. Wear more dresses!

    ReplyDelete
  54. I prefer at the knee. That is really good for you. You look prettier with that length.

    ReplyDelete
  55. I loved this post! I have short calves -- 14 inches. My "magic" number is 2.25, but personally I like the look of my skirt hitting right in the middle of the knee. (And I thought that was the most flattering on you as well) I rarely wear a skirt without heels so I think that helps the overall look. Thanks for the post!

    ReplyDelete
  56. I'm late to the party here, but thank you for your wonderful post. I'm 5'3", almost 60 (yikes), and fashion-challenged. Your info and formula are a big help. I like both skirt lengths on you. The above-the-knee skirts look fun, and would be great for going out. The at-the-knee-length skirts make you look sophisticated and elegant. At my age, my length of choice for myself will be middle of the knee.

    ReplyDelete
  57. I’m not that much of a internet reader to be honest but your sites really
    nice, keep it up! I'll go ahead and bookmark your website to come back in the future. Many thanks
    My web blog ; activex control install

    ReplyDelete
  58. This is a great post! I was searching for dress suits for an upcoming job interview and the skirts all seemed to look odd on me. Do the same rules apply for mini dresses? I think they are more forgiving when it comes to length.

    ReplyDelete
  59. Wow - an oldie but a goodie. I just came across this post through SewPetiteGal (I do read your blog, but this post escaped me!). I haven't done the formula yet as my measuring tape is back home, but I will! xo Ivche

    ReplyDelete
  60. Very helpful post, thank you! I've been trying to figure this out as I'm starting a new job and have been trying to find work appropriate clothing that also doesn't look frumpy. I find that skirts a few inches above the knee look best on me, and the formula says 2" is my ideal. Most work guidelines I've read online advise wearing knee-length skirts, but I don't think they take into account the fact that this doesn't really work with petite proportions. (For the record, my workplace has no guidelines on this and I work with other petite women who seem to favor skirts a few inches above the knee as well.)

    Also, to clarify -- if the formula calls for 50% leg and 50% skirt, then the skirt will need to be higher above the knee if the skirt is high waisted, yes? For example, if my measurement from belly button to knee is 21, and my knee to ankle is 14, that would mean that I need to go 3.5 inches above the knee to keep the proportion correct.

    ReplyDelete
  61. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete

 
Pin It button on image hover